With a killer combination of affordability, utility and fuel economy, the juggernaut compact SUV class is partially responsible for marginalizing the classic family sedan. Perhaps the most recognized small SUVs in this class are the eternally feuding Honda CR-V and redesigned-for-2019 Toyota RAV4, which we tested in a multiday comparison along with five other 2019 models: the updated Hyundai Tucson, updated Jeep Cherokee, Nissan Rogue, redesigned Subaru Forester and defending champion of this test, the Volkswagen Tiguan. None of these are bad SUVs — even last place wasn't far behind most competitors, especially in the subjective categories we judge. Every SUV except for one topped the rest of the field in at least one category. Rather than look at just the winner, we recommend that you find the SUV that's excellent in a way that's important to you.

Read the full results: www.cars.com/articles/whats-the-best-compact-suv-of-2019-1420757644792/?soc=ya-hub-edt-Video-29&aff=yahubedt

See all Cars.com videos: www.cars.com/videos/?soc=ya-hub-edt-Video-14&aff=yahubedt

Cars.com’s Editorial department is your source for automotive news and reviews. In line with Cars.com’s long-standing ethics policy, editors and reviewers don’t accept gifts or free trips from automakers. The Editorial department is independent of Cars.com’s advertising, sales and sponsored content departments.

Comments

    • Franklin Sahagun
      Franklin Sahagun

      MAZDA-CX 5 Turbo charge.,is a killer speed its no.1

      about 5 hours ago
    • Kim Y
      Kim Y

      I actually enjoyed these reviews. I am currently in a 2014 Jeep Cherokee & plan to upgrade to the Cherokee Upland V6. Although Jeep scored next to last, the reason I am shopping for an upgrade immediately eliminated other possibilities in this testing video. Other brands may have tested better overall, but they had drawbacks where I don't want to cut corners. So, for me it wasn't necessarily who's the best, but what are the features of each compact SUV and which one works well for me. So, thanks guys!

      about 16 hours ago
    • Retro-DADE
      Retro-DADE

      There were no SUVs in this video. Only CUVs

      about 23 hours ago
    • MrKeefrichards
      MrKeefrichards

      seriously a vw above a subaru in suv challenge! nah! dont believe a word of this!

      about 1 day ago
    • maurice benton
      maurice benton

      They didnt want all these vehicles to lose to mazda!!!! The hate us real for Mazda here in the US

      about 2 days ago
    • Peter Chen
      Peter Chen

      Pointless

      about 4 days ago
    • Mr. M Knight
      Mr. M Knight

      Great video. I’ll be grabbing my Forester now! Had a great test drive just wanted to justify the purchase :)

      about 5 days ago
    • Zhong Li
      Zhong Li

      How this guys get paid?

      about 7 days ago
    • Rad Sr
      Rad Sr

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cs7PSpIMJYk&list=PLpgIZ0hV59bQZxPDx6PWs1yIFh86PdrtM&index=16&t=520s

      about 9 days ago
    • ltyr2001 1
      ltyr2001 1

      OK! You get a Tiguan and I get a RAV4!
      We have a race: Two hundred thousand miles...

      about 10 days ago
    • 1pilot2000
      1pilot2000

      The best purchasing decision is to purchase a Honda or Toyota SUV! Every other makes are crap!

      about 11 days ago
    • TOM D
      TOM D

      If you are going to do a comparison, do it right....also surprised they left out some top contenders....

      about 12 days ago
    • E. J. Abad
      E. J. Abad

      The CX 5 certainly competes very well with the CRV, RAV 4, Tucson.

      about 12 days ago
    • Craig Ellis
      Craig Ellis

      Bald guy needs a damn shot of caffeine right into his arteries. Talk faster guys we dont have all day.

      about 18 days ago
    • Cat A
      Cat A

      10:18 secs is all I could tolerate.

      about 20 days ago
    • 1000 Sub Challenge
      1000 Sub Challenge

      It amazes me that people still pay premium money for Nissan products. Just no.

      about 22 days ago
    • justintryba
      justintryba

      Really a VW is 1 they are one of the worst car companies

      about 22 days ago
    • Sam Kim
      Sam Kim

      2019 Tucson is awesome!

      about 22 days ago
    • Premium Prem
      Premium Prem

      I have 2014 tiguan r line. Still in great condition never let me down even once, really love it. 😍from NZ

      about 23 days ago
    • Michael Maxwell
      Michael Maxwell

      Edit: I liked the "RAV4" the best

      about 28 days ago
    • Jonathan Losito
      Jonathan Losito

      I’m used to Jeeps and VWs, so I choose the Cherokee and Tiguan.

      about 28 days ago
    • Michael Maxwell
      Michael Maxwell

      How silly. I test drove most of these and liked the 4Runner the best. You have to spend 35K on the VW to get the driver assist features that even the base model RAV4 has. I loved the way the VW looks outside and the inside is very spacious and unique. The turbo lag on the VW KILLED IT for me. It's literally a few seconds of no forward motion when you get on the gas from a start. It was IMPOSSIBLE to drive smoothly. It was either no power or full power and surging ahead. Total deal breaker for me. The CRV , to me is a mommy''s car so off the list. The RAV4 is the only other one with good cargo and cabin space that looks good. The Subaru is just too ugly to own and drive and I don't care how good it is. The RAV4 has too much intake noise at half to full throttle, almost like they added it on purpose but I could live with that one issue. I'm jaded coming from 13 years of blissful 4Runner ownership. Toyota quality is no joke.

      about 28 days ago
    • kubanskiloewe
      kubanskiloewe

      RAV4 Hybrid !!

      about 29 days ago
    • kubanskiloewe
      kubanskiloewe In reply to kubanskiloewe

      @Jonathan Losito i ´m happy taht i bought a 19 year old Lexus Hybrid RX and it is my best car in over 25 years . great quality

      about 27 days ago
    • Jonathan Losito
      Jonathan Losito In reply to kubanskiloewe

      I like the updated Cherokee and the Tiguan!!

      about 27 days ago
    • Сергей С.
      Сергей С.

      Very interesting

      about 1 month ago
    • donald magnuson
      donald magnuson

      I've lived in far northern Minnesota for 55 years.........Subaru.

      about 1 month ago
    • Andy Sleeter
      Andy Sleeter

      Which of these models can match Cherokee's off road ability??

      about 1 month ago
    • Andy Sleeter
      Andy Sleeter In reply to Andy Sleeter

      @danny kelly OK... so at the end of the pavement, these comparisons are over... why then do they show the cars driving on snow where one could lose his life? Even the old VW bug with an air cooled engine emphasized their ability on sand and water

      about 1 month ago
    • danny kelly
      danny kelly In reply to Andy Sleeter

      None especially if you’re talking about the trailhawk

      about 1 month ago
    • lulu lulu
      lulu lulu

      which onw u recommend please for a lady

      about 1 month ago
    • Craig Hawe
      Craig Hawe

      CX-5 Turbo Gas 2.5 ??? #1 by a mile....pathetic.

      about 1 month ago
    • Mike Mac
      Mike Mac In reply to Craig Hawe

      Until you need to put something the trunk area...this goes for the Tuscon as wel

      about 1 month ago
    • Doogy Dog
      Doogy Dog

      I don’t want some damn computer beeping at me, you would have to be crazy to buy that.

      about 1 month ago
    • Eric B.
      Eric B.

      REALLY, no Mazda CX 5 Signature?? No Chevy Equinox??
      My Mazda CX 5 Grand Touring Reserve (2.5 L. turbo and AWD) will STOMP the VW and all others for speed, styling, handling, luxury and safety. The Signature is a $2,000. step above the GT - R with a few touches like Nappa leather instead of "regular" leather, 360 deg. camera, front and rear parking sensors and interior foot lights. BIG DEAL (well, IMHO, not for another $2,000.) But FAR ahead of the top VW Tiguan.

      WHY no Mazda CX 5 GT-R or Signature??
      (And would your REALLY trust the "reliability" of a VW?) VW has one of the lowest returning customer % - for good reason. And yet you rated it #1? 
      This entire rating lineup and lack of some significant models tells me I will never again believe your auto ratings.

      about 1 month ago