With millions of CUVs flying off lots there is no doubt, quantities are not limited. However, as good as many of the affordable options are from Mazda, Hyundai, Honda, and Toyota, many buyers are looking for more luxury and refinement. So jumping to a premium brand like Audi, Mercedes and BMW make sense. We try to break down the pros and cons of stepping up to the BMW X3 30i.

Bendpak is the Official Lift of SavageGeese

Music by: Alan Fowler:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCaITe1zSo1BrS-goyAjExTA
Original Composer: Bo Uwabo 1987

Index:
00:00 - 00:35 Intro
00:35 - 1:35 Exterior Montage
1:35 - 2:20 Interior Intro
2:20 - 8:38 Interior Impressions
8:38 - 12:40 Tech and Infotainment
12:40 - 16:05 In the Shoppe - Suspension and Body
16:05 - 19:00 Under the Hood, Weights, Motor
19:00 - 19:45 Driving Intro
19:45 - 26:45 Driving Impressions
26:45 - 30:30 Final Thoughts

Comments

    • Ian Clancy
      Ian Clancy

      I miss when all BMW’s had the same black VDO gauge cluster. You know the one... e30, e28, e24 etc. Digital gauge cluster will look so dated in 10 years.

      about 21 day ago
    • tehbilbo79
      tehbilbo79

      you missed out by not reviewing one with the B58

      about 1 month ago
    • Qugie
      Qugie

      really iPhone is copying Samsung now. they use to have small phones and now they are getting bigger every year like Samsung.

      about 1 month ago
    • Paul Giulekas
      Paul Giulekas

      you the best car reviewer by far

      about 1 month ago
    • Martin JN
      Martin JN

      Haha, gotta love the differences in the car specs all around the world, I am in the UK and will get my X3 M Sport next month, I am stunned by the differences most notably (perhaps even obvious difference) is the boot (trunk for some), the boot floor and load lip are totally level on UK cars but then we don't have a spare wheel just run flat tyres. The lack of a spare gives extra storage and a dedicated place to put the boot cover, very useful. Nice review and an interesting take on what is good and bad in the car, us brits think the car is huge with masses and masses of space in it.

      about 1 month ago
    • justin g
      justin g

      Very good car review!!!

      about 1 month ago
    • Tim c
      Tim c

      What a depressing voice on this video.

      about 1 month ago
    • N96ZG
      N96ZG

      Great car to have in the warranty, after that, not worth it

      about 2 months ago
    • japanwatchconnection
      japanwatchconnection In reply to N96ZG

      N96ZG Disagree. Besides you can extend the warranty through BMW to 7 years (From in service date) or 125K miles whichever occurs first.

      about 3 days ago
    • mrgrahamersmith
      mrgrahamersmith

      Best review of BMW X3 I’ve seen - and I’ve looked at loads! Thanks.

      about 2 months ago
    • roman walczak
      roman walczak

      RDX is better as far as quality and car overall. 2ND BMW is not what they use to be in 80s and 90s quality went wayyyyyyy down.


      thank you

      about 3 months ago
    • japanwatchconnection
      japanwatchconnection In reply to roman walczak

      roman walczak No more warmed over Honda’s for me.

      about 3 days ago
    • I’m only here for the comment section
      I’m only here for the comment section

      This is the best comprehensive review I’ve seen. Thanks 😊

      about 4 months ago
    • Lokyr00
      Lokyr00

      m40i version of this car with the straight 6 is awesome

      about 4 months ago
    • Amr El Meleegy
      Amr El Meleegy

      Hats off! This is hands down the best X3 review on YouTube. Your final thoughts are spot on. Lots of cool bells and whistles that cost a lot when they break. Buyer beware.

      about 4 months ago
    • japanwatchconnection
      japanwatchconnection In reply to Amr El Meleegy

      Amr El Meleegy And that is true of every single modern car made today. Another cheap shot at BMW by haters

      about 3 days ago
    • bird718
      bird718

      you can get a Jeep Renegade for half the price and still deal the sensors and all that other stuff getting damaged by shopping carts.

      about 5 months ago
    • Dushene Paulusha
      Dushene Paulusha

      please do a review if the benz glc!

      about 5 months ago
    • Will Johnson
      Will Johnson

      No Savage. Just be smart. Don't EVER buy a BMW. EVER. If you have a brain and know anything about automobiles. I am an automotive engineer. BMW's suck. Complexity for complexity sake and how they make their money. They are among the most unreliable cars in the industry. In part because of their complexity but also because of their design. They are not designed for longevity. From their turbo motors to all their body control modules and sensors to their electronic dampers.

      If you were honest and you understand automobiles and without question you do...you would call the brand out for what it is.
      It isn't about nth degree aerodynamics, or fuel efficiency, or weight or .5 seconds 0-60....its about whether the god damn thing will last and they don't. Higher end the BMW, the worse they are. The E-65 should have sunk the company. Only idiots with more money than car savvy would ever own one. Absolute rubbish and you know it but you tip toed around their poor reliability. Toyotas or Hondas do not have this issue. Even American cars are much more reliable.

      about 5 months ago
    • japanwatchconnection
      japanwatchconnection In reply to Will Johnson

      Will Johnson Bull crap. A YT engineer hahahaha. And citing the old E65 a car that went out of production 11-12 years ago.

      about 3 days ago
    • Abso lutely
      Abso lutely In reply to Will Johnson

      Just about every brand is more reliable than BMW. GM products might be the only exception(and only certain GM on the lower end) .. I was at the BMW dealership about to complete the trifecta for German cars and all the customers there told me to walk away now while there's still time. I did leave immediately, lol...... I already own an Audi and a Mercedes Benz and the Benz hasn't been much better. The Audi seems great though.

      about 1 month ago
    • M Fawad M
      M Fawad M

      the best review I came across and believe me, I've been through the entire youtube of reviews...

      about 5 months ago
    • Ace Smooth
      Ace Smooth

      You totally bashed bmw for its complex infotainment system and costly maintenance. Yet, you gave the Volvo XC60 a slap on the wrist for its crap infotainment system and everyone hiding the truth about its expensive maintenance too. I have yet to see any complain about Audi high maintenance costs but they pay every organization to overlook that major aspect.

      about 6 months ago
    • japanwatchconnection
      japanwatchconnection In reply to Ace Smooth

      Ace Smooth Amen! Well said!

      about 3 days ago
    • japanwatchconnection
      japanwatchconnection In reply to Ace Smooth

      Abso lutely Lies and more lies from Audi salesmen and fanbois. fact: Audi’s are notorious and suffer from chronic electrical problems just as their VW counterparts. And Audi dealers have a terrible reputation for service. fact!

      about 3 days ago
    • Abso lutely
      Abso lutely In reply to Ace Smooth

      Audi's repair costs and maintenance is nowhere near as expensive as BMW. In a nutshell, they are far more reliable. Just a fact.

      about 1 month ago
    • savagegeese
      savagegeese In reply to Ace Smooth

      I absolutely tore Volvo apart.on the XC90 video about infotainment.

      about 6 months ago
    • Yangorang
      Yangorang

      What's a good BMW shop in the area you'd recommend?

      about 6 months ago
    • savagegeese
      savagegeese In reply to Yangorang

      @Yangorang German Auto Werks

      1391 Industrial Dr, Unit A, Lake in the Hills, Illinois 60156
      Owner is Mike, tell him Savagegeese sent you.

      about 6 months ago
    • Yangorang
      Yangorang In reply to Yangorang

      @savagegeese In Chicagoland area if you know any.

      about 6 months ago
    • savagegeese
      savagegeese In reply to Yangorang

      Northern Illinois?

      about 6 months ago
    • Anthony Rios
      Anthony Rios

      Curious if it’s worth skipping the AWD altogether especially based on your driving observations. great review as always - this was a rewatch as i’m interested in getting an x3

      about 6 months ago
    • miki k
      miki k

      at 18:40" in summary a money pit, so it drives amazingly to the shop where you sell your other kidney to keep it going

      about 6 months ago
    • japanwatchconnection
      japanwatchconnection In reply to miki k

      miki k And what POS do you drive by the way?

      about 3 days ago
    • AJ Lee
      AJ Lee

      @11:28 there’s a fix to this. If you use a certain function often in the menu and you want to get to it with a physical button, you can save it as a preset (1-8 keys) by just holding down on the preset button.

      about 6 months ago
    • Lasse Kviesgaard
      Lasse Kviesgaard

      The sound of a four cylinder is just sooo boring regardless of HP

      about 6 months ago
    • Andrei Motinga
      Andrei Motinga

      @savagegeese, could you please make a review of 2014-2018 bmw x5? I'd like to buy one, it would be very cool to see your review of it.

      about 7 months ago
    • Sri Rangaswamy
      Sri Rangaswamy

      Thanks for the detailed review Savage! Its a lovely city/out of town drive SUV! Cheers

      about 7 months ago
    • Pilski 1955
      Pilski 1955

      Certainly agree with vast majority of positive comments on your reviews; presentation, music, MUSIC, camera work, honesty, candidness, etc. Keep it up. Now...why I, having the $$ for a BMW would NEVER own or lease one.
      (I'm an auto enthusiast, love to drive hard, especially in the twisties, and have loved BMW's since the first 2002 was imported. To explain to 98% of those reading this...NOT the year 2002, but the model number of the 1st high volume BMW's imported to the US...app. 50 years ago.)

      1. I DO NOT buy ANYTHING just to have the name or badge!

      2. Terrible value when considering reliability, dealer (at least the one here) "service"(?) and inconsiderate (spelled LYING) sales personnel. Ex.- friend bought a 3 series sedan... "...it was supposed to be green, but another salesman sold the one we put a deposit on..." Asked if the color was available from another dealer and was told..."we don't do that"...dealer swap. (My Acura dealer has gone nearly 500 MILES to swap for a color I wanted...over 200 another time!!!) Gluttons for punishment, friend's' next car was an X3. "...we wanted a blue one, but the dealer said they only IMPORTED a limited number of that color..." IMPORTED...from SPARTANBURG, SOUTH CAROLINA to Florida????? They believed him!!!...wanted that badge that bad. No other reason...driving machine??? ...friend doesn't know oversteer from the b-pillar.

      Which, sadly is the case for, probably, MOST BMW owners/lessees...just gotta have that badge, of which maybe 1% know it represents a spinning propeller! Fortunately, I didn't get sucked in to the "got to have badge" syndrome...ever and am thankful for it. Not limited to spinning propeller...same applies to the 3-pointed swastika, the connected zeroes and the brand I drove for over 20 years...when it was a VALUE to do so...Volvo. Yes, yuppies and younger...you DO learn things regarding value and sensible buying in 82 years of life...you'll see!

      about 8 months ago
    • ckneasel
      ckneasel

      Really nice review of the X3... I’m in the market for an X3M40i, GLC43, Macan S and this was a helpful video on the underpinnings and driving impression...

      about 8 months ago
    • KvnS S
      KvnS S

      I still can't believe that we, as consumers, let BMW get away with charging a monthly fee to use Apple CarPlay. I hope no other manufacturers hop on that, but I'm betting they will

      about 8 months ago
    • Q M
      Q M

      They actually have a HUD button on the 4-series. It is helpful, but I find the HUD settings in iDrive is not that hard to find, after you finally find it. I sell BMWs, and am very happy with the new X3. It is a big improvement from the previous gen. BMW does a lot for their customers, and the iDrive system is the best. Yes it is expensive out of warranty to maintain, but you get what you pay for with the build quality. Also, you can program menu items, by shortcutting them on the radio keys. Pretty user friendly. All you do is have the menu item highlighted/selected in red, then press and hold the key you want to designate that menu item to.

      about 8 months ago
    • Rog Burton
      Rog Burton

      By a street mile ... this video is the best piece of information sharing about the BMW X3 on Youtube. The depth of both criticism and praise for different elements of the entire process is good and accentuates the way in which it was executed. It shows a deep level of knowledge and know-how, and reasons for doing things in engineering terms. It shows a gracious approach to the brand marque and is neither cynical nor over the top. I immediately related to quite a few comments made, and especially about the high-tech infotainment system ... but luckily for me, even though I'm retirement age I am an engineer with experience in computers/iphones and digital general, so I guess for me easier to absorb. But the comments are very accurate about everything, especially the digital systems. I chased around looking for a good video, as I intended to look to buy an X3 ... and buy one I did, mostly after much thought and several sessions on this video. Thank you for being "structural" and unsympathetic in your video, but at the same time ... telling it as it is, unlike some of the other supergloss trade videos and car magazine efforts. I bought a 2019 BMW X3 M40D and have to say, yes there's an awefull lot to go wrong ... but at the moment it's an awesome SUV and simply love it ... after learning how to fly it.

      about 8 months ago
    • Sean
      Sean

      Why does this seem different to the 2019 BMW X3? Am I missing something here, bit confused...Why is there are a spare tyre? This car is on run flats isn't it? Why is there a lip in the trunk? It should be perfectly flat?

      about 8 months ago
    • due nguyen
      due nguyen

      Nice dude

      about 9 months ago
    • Jincheng Liu
      Jincheng Liu

      can you please do a detailed review of the bmw x1

      about 9 months ago
    • Alex
      Alex

      The cons are far from being dealbreakers. Those future potential tech problems will likely surface after 5 years of ownership. For people like me who lease, we won’t be seeing those issues at all. As for the price, let’s be honest, most BMW buyers can can comfortably afford it.

      about 9 months ago
    • Philip Waters
      Philip Waters

      THAT was a great video! Thanks heaps mate! We’re picking one up tomorrow at 10.30 and this was (seriously) the best, most informative video I’ve come across. Loved the undercarriage show and tell! Keep up the good work!!..... Subscribed.

      about 9 months ago
    • Transit 8
      Transit 8

      Nothing, compares to the BMW 3 Series. The best model designation in automotive history! Its been a coupe, convertible, sedan, wagon, super-car, SUV & electric.

      about 9 months ago
    • Simmer Pete
      Simmer Pete

      Best way to buy one is the executive demo. They’re up to 20% off and still qualify for all new discounts. And they have under 5,000 miles on them. So you basically don’t have to worry about the initial depression.

      about 9 months ago
    • Ian Tovey
      Ian Tovey

      Great review and attention to detail. Thank you Peter.

      about 9 months ago
    • Rajesh Veedu
      Rajesh Veedu

      Brilliant review! So engrossing and informative. So much better than the drama of some and a much more better than the nincompoops who talk about cup holders and glove compartments. Thank you!

      about 9 months ago
    • Chris Kirkman
      Chris Kirkman

      I'm telling you something you already know, but it always feel nice when someone tells you this is an awesome review.

      about 9 months ago
    • Cocoy C
      Cocoy C

      Playlist - "BMW water pump failure!!" lol

      about 9 months ago
    • soloclickads
      soloclickads

      Thanks.

      about 10 months ago
    • Jack Sailor
      Jack Sailor

      HARMOM KARDON ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))

      about 10 months ago
    • Waldemar Ishibashi
      Waldemar Ishibashi

      Would be nice if any Japanese company copy-pasted the shape and utility. Being able to rest two elbows at the same time for motorway driving is not high tech.
      Lexus doesn`t offer trunk space besides LX. RAV4 is simply uncomfortable for someone 5ft5 (170cm) in height. Same goes for Forester.
      Having a spare tire is also a forgotten feature - in a SUV with AWD!
      I live in Japan, want to go outdoors and it is likely that I will have to buy Cherokee Trailhawk. Shame for Japan, kudos for America and Germany for design utilitarian vehicles.

      about 10 months ago
    • Todd Eosso
      Todd Eosso

      It's not complicated. I have an x5 same system all you have to say is "heads up display" and it takes you to the menu, same for any system.

      about 10 months ago
    • Jake Kennedy
      Jake Kennedy

      I bought one of these because of this review. Seriously great stuff! No one else talks about the underside of cars and why luxury manufacturers like BMW are different than a Ford or Kia. Thank you!

      about 10 months ago
    • Simon Harris
      Simon Harris

      This 3rd generation X3 isn't made in America its made in South Africa. Second gen X3 was made in America.

      about 10 months ago
    • ACardenas1
      ACardenas1

      You whine so damn much. Jesus. Worse than a woman. "Gentlemen's Club". Yeah right, who are you trying to fool.

      about 10 months ago
    • 22chachalaca
      22chachalaca

      No Vented seats when you're spending all that money??? My 07 Lexus es350 has vented seats.

      about 10 months ago
    • Tell it Like it is
      Tell it Like it is

      If its not built in Germany I won't be buying it.

      about 10 months ago
    • John Gaudet
      John Gaudet

      The X3 M will be a total beast!

      about 10 months ago
    • John Gaudet
      John Gaudet

      Great review, I like you opinion on things. I test drove a m40i yesterday it was amazing sporty and fast.

      about 10 months ago
    • jmvallejo
      jmvallejo

      I own on of these X3, I 've seen hundreds of reviews about them. Let me tell you that this is the best and the most honest review amongst any other I saw. Thanks!!

      about 11 months ago
    • E.S.M.
      E.S.M.

      Thank you for your incredible reviews!! Extremely Professional!!! So...what's your choice: X3 or Q5..or....?

      about 11 months ago
    • Chris Lee
      Chris Lee

      been meaning to comment for
      awhile.. you top all other want to be automobile reviewers.. great work!!!

      about 11 months ago
    • Nigel
      Nigel

      Great review, buying one this week

      about 11 months ago
    • richard higson
      richard higson

      Well shit in my hat and punch it! i bought one of these today msport 3.0 , love it ! best reviewer i think i have everseen he is just so on the ball and the money , he asborbs and feels his way through the vehicle and uncovers the good and the bad plus the ugly! Superb reviewer ! p.s. drive a 30d M sport !!!!!!

      about 11 months ago
    • kubanskiloewe
      kubanskiloewe

      i choose a old RX450h instead of this and never looked back ...greetings from germany. This X3 weighs 1950kg in 2019; a 10 year old RX450h with a 3,5ltrV6 plus Hybrid weighs 2150kg which i think is not so bad for a over 10 year old Luxury SUV without having so much aluminium but airsuspension ;-)

      about 11 months ago
    • Abso lutely
      Abso lutely In reply to kubanskiloewe

      My mom has a 2007 RX450h and it's been bulletproof for the past 13 years. I told her to keep it as long as she can because it was rated as the most reliable hybrid ever.

      about 1 month ago
    • Robert Devoy
      Robert Devoy

      Does it have a plastic radiator and exhaust manifold? How does the engine compare to the Audio 2.0 ltr turbo engine that was raved about in the review of the Audi A-5?

      about 1 year ago
    • T C
      T C

      BMW’s aren’t worth anything after the warranty runs out. BMW’s need to work on reliability. They are endless money pits.

      about 1 year ago
    • kevin n
      kevin n

      Great review. I'd love to buy a M40i but it's 13k more than the 30i... I wonder how the M sport package impacts the driving experience..

      about 1 year ago
    • Bob Bowie
      Bob Bowie

      BMWs interior have never felt special.. Its always cold cheap and basic

      about 1 year ago
    • japanwatchconnection
      japanwatchconnection In reply to Bob Bowie

      Bob Bowie and how’s that KIA interior doing these days?

      about 3 days ago
    • The Lifestylez
      The Lifestylez

      Like your taste in music bro! Stay lit 😂

      about 1 year ago
    • Valentin Marin
      Valentin Marin

      Un buen coche...Me gusta...lo compraria hasta de segunda mano si lo necesitaría

      about 1 year ago
    • ladenree31
      ladenree31

      Hello from France 🇫🇷 ! I ordered last week a BMW X3 M Sport package and I’ll receive it in June. Your report is the best I’ve never seen about the X3.

      about 1 year ago
    • herbet modise
      herbet modise

      Good review. 👌 detailed explanation.

      about 1 year ago
    • Hsiu Chang
      Hsiu Chang

      Why don't you comment on the way it looks and what it actually cost I think you're trying to deceive deceive your viewers, you have no problems mentioning the price of Lexus though,
      the newer Mazda SUVs Drive even better than this BMW and I think theInteriors as good not to mention reliability is going to be better then this overpriced car

      about 1 year ago
    • Light Breeze Cruisin'
      Light Breeze Cruisin'

      Best X3 walk-through on YouTube.

      about 1 year ago
    • 86mikeyy
      86mikeyy

      Can you turn off the auto start stop?

      about 1 year ago
    • Doug Smith
      Doug Smith

      Overpriced pos

      about 1 year ago
    • Cross Ocean
      Cross Ocean

      Agree. Six cylinders would fit better with this car. Have the 4 cylinder and its okay, but not great.

      about 1 year ago
    • 6SpeedTA95
      6SpeedTA95

      You should do something similar on the Q5/SQ5. I think it feels more solid when compared with the BMW, but the BMW drives more sporty.

      Edit: Didn't realize you had already done the Audi as well. Great stuff here as usual

      about 1 year ago
    • SBha30
      SBha30

      Pretty much a perfect review in my opinion. I am looking forward to his review of the new X5.

      about 1 year ago
    • Gkoulidis
      Gkoulidis

      Is it that BMW does not use run flats in the US? I mean it is clear that the tire under the cargo place looks like and actually is an after thought.

      PS: So the car has run-flats but still carries a fifth wheel??

      about 1 year ago
    • Judson Zhao
      Judson Zhao

      gentleman's club lmao. BTW why does BMW make these in the states but with a Britain accent?

      about 1 year ago
    • Zhao Guang
      Zhao Guang

      That movable part on driver's seat is the most useless feature. That part is not heated; so in winter only 60% of the seat pad is heated. I'd rather have the regular seat.

      about 1 year ago
    • Zhao Guang
      Zhao Guang

      Com'on, how much money BMW paid you? Memory seat is not standard, it's in a $2000 option. Lumbar support is option too. Almost all cars Hyundai/Kia/Mazda come with standard features that is an option on BMW/Audi/Benz.

      about 1 year ago
    • Read Zechariah 12:10
      Read Zechariah 12:10

      As usual, a terrific review. The interior touch screen jutting out of the dash is a horrendous design idea, many manufacturers are doing this now including Mazda and it is just the worst thoughtless poorest design I've ever seen. The way to do the screen properly is the way that it is done in the Porsche Macan. Integrated into the dash excellent in its intuitiveness and function. Savage geese has become the best car reviewer on YouTube.

      about 1 year ago
    • RON H
      RON H

      Just discovered your channel. Great review, very thorough, good information on the negatives as well as the positives

      about 1 year ago
    • manifest 73
      manifest 73

      I still own a 2016 X4 335i, there a a few rattles in the car due to the OEM run flat tires. After replacing those tires with regular ones the rattles are less noticable.

      about 1 year ago