IIHS: Tesla Model S, BMW i3 fall short in recent crash tests

The Chevy Volt and Toyota Prius Prime are still the safest plug-in picks.

To be an IIHS Top Safety Pick, cars must achieve a "good" rating in the five crash tests, and have an "advanced" or "superior" available front crash prevention system. Having headlights rated "good" or "acceptable" give it the "plus" rating. While plug-in vehicles like the Toyota Prius Prime and the Chevrolet Volt have earned the IIHS 2017 Top Safety Pick+ award, the recently evaluated Tesla Model S and the BMW i3 come up short.

In the small overlap front crash test, the Tesla's safety belt didn't prevent the dummy's head from hitting the steering wheel through the airbag. The IIHS also noted a possible leg injury in that test. Tesla said it would fix this issue in cars produced beginning January 26, so now its IIHS' turn to smash the car up again to see if its rating improves.

Interestingly, the P100D variant only earns an "acceptable" rating in the rollover test. The roof strength is no different from the rest of the Model S lineup, which are rated "good," but the weight of its big battery puts more stress on the structure while shiny-side-down. Finally, its headlights get a "poor" rating from the IIHS.

The BMW i3's biggest shortcoming is in its head restraints. In a rear-end collision, it only gets an "acceptable" rating, which puts occupants at a greater risk of a neck injury. The IIHS laments that the i3 is the only vehicle in the small car category that doesn't get a "good" rating in this test. The i3's headlights also miss the mark, as the only option gets an "acceptable" rating.

"There's no reason that the most efficient vehicles can't be among the safest," says David Zuby, IIHS chief research officer. If you're wondering about the Chevrolet Bolt, the IIHS says it'll obliterate examples of it in the name of safety later this year.

"small, moderate overlap IIHS crash test 2016"

"SUBSCRIBE NOW"

Comments

    • AutoShow
      AutoShow

      Constance - The Descent - Kevin MacLeod
      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=puVz8taSANE

      about 2 years ago
    • Аюр Аюров
      Аюр Аюров In reply to AutoShow

      автор, я пожаловался на это видео (жестокие или отталкивающие сцены) так как меня чуть удар не хватил когда я увидел как бьют новую теслу и чуть не умер от зависти :(((
      author, I complained about this video (brutal or repulsive scenes) because I was a little pissed when I saw how they beat the new tesla and almost died of envy: (((

      about 1 year ago
    • JBL BOIS
      JBL BOIS In reply to AutoShow

      Auto Sho

      about 1 year ago
    • Wali Mo
      Wali Mo In reply to AutoShow

      Auto Show v

      about 1 year ago
    • humza bhagat
      humza bhagat

      0:29 that car has a self es team heart. I mean look. Just doesn’t stop,

      about 27 days ago
    • General Zirkobi
      General Zirkobi

      Wow, I already knew that BMW's were horrible cars, but as unsafe as this model is I'd vote for them to be shut down fully.

      about 2 months ago
    • InfinityPlayz
      InfinityPlayz

      Tesla’s can be very violent

      about 2 months ago
    • Eric
      Eric

      atleast you sent the electronics to rich rebuilds right

      about 3 months ago
    • Tarmack
      Tarmack

      Why do they not show rear end collisions? most of the accidents a self drive car will be in is going to be the car rear ended bye someone.

      about 3 months ago
    • Qwertworks
      Qwertworks

      I still find it impressive how fast the airbags deploy!

      about 4 months ago
    • Sergiusz Olszewski
      Sergiusz Olszewski

      3:50 front crash prevention - Tesla: not available, BMW: advanced. Oh boi.

      about 4 months ago
    • Veydr
      Veydr

      Бмв и Тесла говно, Лада the best. .

      about 4 months ago
    • Ventana Oculta
      Ventana Oculta In reply to Veydr

      Idiot?

      about 1 month ago
    • Catboy219
      Catboy219

      I thought tesla was going to be caught on fire

      about 5 months ago
    • Okao Okao
      Okao Okao

      Bmw airbags are better

      about 5 months ago
    • blazortheepic03
      blazortheepic03

      The i3 is a disgusting piece of shit

      about 5 months ago
    • samconroy
      samconroy

      The real MVP is the person cleaning all these messes up.

      about 5 months ago
    • Juan Padilla
      Juan Padilla

      The i3s body is pretty much all carbon fiber mates

      about 5 months ago
    • человек
      человек

      Also you are a bike with a motorcycle compare!

      about 5 months ago
    • zhurbich
      zhurbich

      This guy is a boring speaker

      about 5 months ago
    • Alex Ganz
      Alex Ganz

      OR you can drive like normal human being and not crash :)

      about 5 months ago
    • Murillo Life Style
      Murillo Life Style

      I want the car hitting the cars at 1:54, that thing didn't even budge one bit😧 looks way more solid then both the bmw and tesla

      about 5 months ago
    • Raphaelxxl 14
      Raphaelxxl 14

      I feel sad for does poor car

      about 5 months ago
    • Killer Clown Productions
      Killer Clown Productions

      I used to build the "test barriers" they smash into . They would moan if there was a blemish on the paint work only to smash a car into it 😂. The actual barriers are made of honeycomb metal . Each section has different tensile strength to replicate another car.

      about 5 months ago
    • Zoya Spencer
      Zoya Spencer

      So big heavy sedan vs lightweight small car.

      about 5 months ago
    • marklola12
      marklola12

      back passenger in the tesla is dead lol the airbag curtain did not even go near its head

      about 5 months ago
    • MrManny
      MrManny

      Bmw good

      about 5 months ago
    • Jethro Chan
      Jethro Chan

      there’s a update on model s https://www.iihs.org/iihs/ratings/vehicle/v/tesla/model-s-4-door-hatchback

      about 5 months ago
    • Hunter XXL
      Hunter XXL

      1:49 the mbw is not that easy

      about 5 months ago
    • Hunter XXL
      Hunter XXL

      0:22 first time i was like ok the left part is gone

      about 5 months ago
    • Michael theGreat
      Michael theGreat

      Tesla is amazing as always

      about 5 months ago
    • Robert H
      Robert H

      I like Tesla, but golly is the Tesla cult strong in these comments.

      about 5 months ago
    • Desmond Deshawn Cannon Jr
      Desmond Deshawn Cannon Jr

      2:30 It's a Wasp LOL

      about 5 months ago
    • Rasmus Rasmussen
      Rasmus Rasmussen

      Wow the Tesla is way to stiff. Not safe at all.

      about 5 months ago