Our 2016 Midsize Pickup Challenge panel of judges had the chance to flog each of the 4x4 competitors at a private off road park just outside Ann Arbor, MI. We played in the sand, on hill climbs, over rocky trails, even playing in the mud. What we discovered surprised us.

Like what you see? Follow Cars.com! Subscribe now to get the latest YouTube videos from Cars.com:
On Facebook:
On Twitter:
On Instagram:
More Cars.com reviews:
The latest car news: www.cars.com/news/


    • Kao sa3l33
      Kao sa3l33

      Frontier is the best just because of poor frontier.

      about 12 days ago
    • Kao sa3l33
      Kao sa3l33

      Bunch of frontier sympathizer. Go for the underdog (garbage)...Typical shit.

      about 12 days ago
    • Spenser Hawk
      Spenser Hawk

      You get the same bullshit from everyone about the Frontier. It's old, the interior is dated and it doesn't have a 60 inch touchscreen. Guess what??? No one complains about its off road capability nor its engine and transmission reliability. Keep your looks, your bigger touchscreen, etc. I'd rather have the bulletproof drivetrain.

      about 22 days ago
    • Alan Joseph
      Alan Joseph

      So wheres the dodge dakota

      about 1 month ago
    • Hughhefnerd

      Wow what a terrible "highlight reel" .. Seems like car guys driving trucks for the 1st time. Complaining about a DIAL, the pencil neck saying "what i dont like about the frontier is its is a frontier..." You guys suck!

      about 1 month ago
    • Gee_cee -me
      Gee_cee -me

      Wait. Did the Ridgeline make it up the hill?! 🤔

      about 1 month ago
    • Steven Garcia
      Steven Garcia In reply to Gee_cee -me


      about 1 month ago
    • CryTec

      Haha they were scared to bring a ford

      about 1 month ago
    • rk h
      rk h

      every one of those trucks are ugly. i would rather drive a nissan hard body from the 80's

      about 2 months ago
    • TM Feldman
      TM Feldman

      In 4:28 you're going to tell me something important about anything... I don't think so!

      about 2 months ago
    • Bookie Anderson
      Bookie Anderson

      these journalist douche bags suck a lot of cock

      about 2 months ago
    • Tyler Sutton
      Tyler Sutton

      No ford truck???? Not even worth watching i dont buy junk.

      about 3 months ago
    • ZEROKOOL-20

      Best way, put the size tires on all of them..

      about 4 months ago
    • Travis H
      Travis H

      These guys are idiots...I think house wife's would do better at "judging" how they did.

      about 4 months ago
    • Bryant Matthews
      Bryant Matthews

      Shid pro x4 off road lol

      about 5 months ago
    • Frank Last
      Frank Last

      4 trucks and a crossover with a bed

      about 5 months ago
    • Charlie Vuedoo
      Charlie Vuedoo

      I love my 2012 pro4x

      about 6 months ago
    • Michael Knight
      Michael Knight

      I drive a pro 4x xterra it's a beast

      about 6 months ago
    • Michael Knight
      Michael Knight

      I'll take the nissan over all of them less bullshit to break

      about 6 months ago
    • Eric Buchta
      Eric Buchta

      Good thing there driving the cheaper mid size trucks. What are they now, a measly 38,000. That’s pennies. You know!

      about 7 months ago
    • Slickpickle

      I hate how they use the factory tires. Put the same tires on all the trucks and then do a test..

      about 8 months ago
    • Stephen Hearn
      Stephen Hearn

      The host of this video had nothing but negative comments about every vehicle.

      about 8 months ago
    • Higginsamerica

      The Honda is really ugly

      about 9 months ago
    • Camaro69 Green
      Camaro69 Green

      They all suck. Little under powered trucks trying to be powerful..... trying to be OFF ROAD machines. These are built and sold to the public...They all suck, however...they all could be great off road trucks if equipped with after market parts that would give these economical trucks what they need. Then they would all be great. So key board monkeys.... stop bashing the other brand. We should be glad that we can go out and buy these cool little trucks! Your lucky.

      about 9 months ago
    • stephan burgess
      stephan burgess

      You guys are just unlucky you don't have the Mitsubishi Triton. A dam good ute.

      about 10 months ago
    • Ready for Anything
      Ready for Anything

      I don't think the Canyon got a fair shake here, should have tested the All Terrain version that is actually designed for light off roading like the Z71, Pro-4X, and TRD Off Road they used in the other 3 trucks that mattered.  The Honda...meh.  It's a Honda, doesn't even have 4WD, just AWD which isn't the same.

      about 10 months ago
    • Shane Person
      Shane Person

      Lol I'm a Chevy man till death! But none of them will ever!! Stand up to Toyota!

      about 10 months ago

      I heard the ford ranger is the truck of choice in Australia....too bad we dont have em here...I'll stick to my f150

      about 11 months ago
    • mobley Mobley
      mobley Mobley

      Midsize trucks are like softcore porn. I won't even look at it.

      about 1 year ago
    • PureCountryof91

      Colorado and canyon are the same pile of shit. The ridge line is a car. This better get a redo when the ranger comes home..

      about 1 year ago
    • crazy cowgirl
      crazy cowgirl

      what I do not like about these trucks is why do the all have to have double cabs?? whaat happen to the normal 2 door truck..

      about 1 year ago