Subscribe to SCD-TV:

911Rs are currently trading for Carrera GT money so we felt we had to bring both cars together and delve deeper into the debate with the help of Carl Hartley and a lucky owner of a 911R. Which one will be worth more in 20 years - please comment below!

Follow Carl Hartley on Instagram:

Snapchat: supercardriver


    • Jason Tietnan
      Jason Tietnan

      What a nice problem to have!

      about 24 days ago
    • Baldeagle301

      Nice car but the f40 is the best car ever

      about 3 months ago
    • srettab

      this video is a bucket of stereotypes
      he is saying all the things he ''should'' have said
      like filling in all checkboxes

      about 6 months ago
    • Edison73100

      Not even close. CGT.

      about 8 months ago
    • Hungrytongues 69
      Hungrytongues 69

      I must add - there’s more to the rawness of the Carrera GT than its whacky manual. The lack of stability and traction control... scary

      about 8 months ago
    • Hungrytongues 69
      Hungrytongues 69

      I don’t see any case for the 911R. Not in sex appeal, not in driving experience, and sadly, not in value appreciation. I just hope the Carrera GT is still under a million dollars in a decade, so that I can buy one

      about 8 months ago
    • Martin Böckmann
      Martin Böckmann

      "Does the R sound like this?" -case closed!

      about 10 months ago
    • jon bell
      jon bell

      I thought from the title this was going to be a performance handling comparison,but its more like an investors tutorial

      about 10 months ago
      TheSUPERCARDRIVER In reply to jon bell

      One for future for sure, but we shot this at the time 911R's were going for the same money as a CGT so we thought it was a good topic of conversation :)

      about 10 months ago
    • rexsolomon

      Ah, let me see. One is made of carbon fiber, has a Formula 1 10 cylinder engine and is one series only, no more. The other is steel and aluminium, a 6 cylinder engine and has been serialized over many decades. ARE YOU KIDDING ME? The value of one today is in the millions and the other over a hundred thousand. Such a dumb question. CGT is best! It's a certified 100% WIDOW MAKER!

      about 11 months ago
    • S b
      S b

      well 2 years later...he should of swapped that trading at 320-375 the gt is now 800K +

      about 11 months ago
    • Tom Fidler
      Tom Fidler

      jesus imagine if you payed 600k for a 991r

      about 11 months ago
    • Boxsterholics

      The 959 was the first extreme Porsche.

      about 1 year ago
    • british people yellow teeth
      british people yellow teeth

      cgt is for mans and the 911r is for ladies or daddys kid.......

      about 1 year ago
    • spudnic88

      Stupid twat does not know how to pronounce Porsche...............idiot

      about 1 year ago
    • Spawn223311

      CGT for daysss. V10 mid-engine manual supercar Porsche

      about 1 year ago
    • Gumpy 49
      Gumpy 49

      Much rather have a gt3 rs over the 911r, I don’t think its a great looking car without the aero bits of the rs, and who wouldn’t have a cgt over the 911r?

      about 1 year ago
    • Gumpy 49
      Gumpy 49

      Who’d pay 600k for a 911r when a gt3 rs is essentially the same car but with a pdk box so therefore it’s probably faster

      about 1 year ago
    • Michael Christl
      Michael Christl

      Hi, would be interesting to know, if Mr. Porsche would visit you and introducing himself: "Hello, I am Wolfgang Porsche...", would you continue to call him "Porsch"...?? What kind of car-"fanatic" cannot even pronounce the name of the company properly..??

      about 1 year ago
    • Owen Chua
      Owen Chua

      911. Carrera GT is great for a few but I don't really like because of its design

      about 1 year ago
    • Jürgenk

      Guys you gone nuts. Regardless of how desirable and pure 911R may seem nowadays the choice between these two is so fuckin obvious :)

      about 1 year ago
    • Nikola Dietmar Krapp
      Nikola Dietmar Krapp

      what kind of boyracernewbie drives with a hand on the gearlever all the time???

      about 1 year ago
    • SC&DC Sports cars and diecast Channel
      SC&DC Sports cars and diecast Channel

      911 R looks like Renault Clio compared to CGT ;)

      about 1 year ago
    • Peter benn pan
      Peter benn pan

      I seen a silver porsche 911 R in Harrogate about 6 months ago for sale for £419.995. They also had a maclaren 675 LT in white and a aventador SV in blue. They also had Ferraris and near enough every other sports car you could think of. I think its called GC motors 😎. Worth a look if you have the money to spend 😆

      about 1 year ago
    • Christophe B
      Christophe B

      Come on! There could possibly no other car more desirable than the CGT. The 911 R is just a overpriced 911 to me.

      about 1 year ago
      TheSUPERCARDRIVER In reply to Christophe B

      right answer!!

      about 1 year ago
    • rassta baboul
      rassta baboul

      I would have prefered to hear the sound of the v10 rather than your blabla

      about 2 years ago
    • Marx Mann
      Marx Mann

      the carrera gt sound is a replica sound of the Mazda rx767 & 787b,it's a hell of a precision tool for the track

      about 2 years ago
    • MemoryLaneCinema

      The 911 r is not special anymore when the new gt3 comes with a manual

      about 2 years ago
    • 0wen

      Hartley is a smug wanker

      about 2 years ago
    • Shaihan Rasheed
      Shaihan Rasheed

      GT3 drives itself? What the........! Have u actually driven a 991 GT3 flat out on a circuit? when the 991 GT3 came out, It won EVO car of the year 2013, autocar best drivers car 2013 and car magazine sports car giant test 2013. And that's because of the hardcore, uncompromising and pure track-focused driving experience the GT3 provides, as it's all about the driving. Yh, my ass the GT3 'drives by itself' when it was clearly designed as a hardcore track machine where the driver has to concentrate at max to extract every last bit of performance potential out of it on a circuit.

      about 2 years ago
      TheSUPERCARDRIVER In reply to Shaihan Rasheed

      I think it was more of a tongue in cheek comment which has certainly caused some controversy on here. Compared to the CGT the GT3 drives itself, by the way it's PDK only - not physically driving the car on the limit but we do see how it comes across that way... thanks anyway for watching !

      about 2 years ago
    • Ajinkya Ranadive
      Ajinkya Ranadive

      The 911R is brilliant, and desirable, could still buy other manual 911s (a 991 GTS, or one of the 997 or 996 generation models) and have a similar driving experience if you really wanted a manual naturally aspirated 911.
      The Carrera GT, on the other hand, is utterly unique. Basically a Le Mans car for the road with a 600 hp mid-mounted V10 that revs to 8400 rpm. It is arguably the greatest analogue supercar ever made, along with the Ferrari F40 and the McLaren F1.

      about 2 years ago